Best Comics, Collectibles and Memorabilia to Sell on eBay

Marketplaces 101
Best Comics, Collectibles and Memorabilia to Sell on eBay

eBay is a great place to sell comic books, collectibles, and memorabilia because you are not limited to just selling in the US; you can sell internationally via using eBay's Global Shipping program. There are also a ton of collectors on eBay, and if you sell the right kind of items (i.e. hard to find) you can make a lot of money. If you've ever browsed through your local thrift store, chances are you've come across some of the items mentioned below.  We've put on our research hat and sought out the best comic books, collectibles, and memorabilia to sell on eBay according to Terapeak.


Comic Books


Comic book collectors have a deep respect for the value of their collections. They take pride in displaying a rare issue that makes comic book fans envious. But when you're ready to sell it all, don't fear! You might be surprised by how many different reasons people choose to sell over keeping these prized possessions in storage or filing away at them until they collect dust somewhere else on your property - like under furniture that's been there since before either one of us was born (or maybe even prior). Now finding out the value of comic books can be overwhelming, particularly when you encounter a lot of conflicting pricing online. Here are the top 2 things to take note of when pricing your comic book on eBay:


Know Your Comic Book Grades


Comic book collectors usually store their books in protective sleeves or boxes to avoid damage. However, even small dents and tears can make a huge difference when it comes time to sell it. Grading a comic book simply means referring to the condition that it's in. Although this can be completely subjective, there is a 10-point grading scale starting from gem mint (10) to poor (0.5). To determine the grade of your comic, you can either scour forums, take it to a local comic book store to get an appraisal or use Certified Guaranty Company to weigh in credibility.


Comic Book Age and Value


The most popular era for books is the late 80s and early 90s. Age definitely contributes to the sale price, but it's not the only factor. The market demand also creates value. For example, a newer book could have a higher demand than an older one. In short, age and value are both factors that need to be considered on a case-by-case basis.


Check out this helpful article on Top Tips to Sell Comic Books on eBay


According to eBay's Terapeak dates ranging from November 2021 and November 2022, these are the top 5 best-selling comic books:


Amazing Fantasy #15 Spider-Man 1st Appearance (publication year: 1962)

Highest sold: $450k on April 14, 2022

Highest available market price: $500k with 260 watchers


Amazing Fantasy #15 Spider-Man 1st Appearance


Werewolf By Night #32 (publication year: 1975)

Highest sold: $65k on April 8, 2022

Highest available market price: $20k with 20 watchers


All Star Comics #8 (publication year: 1941)

Highest sold: $94k on Feb. 8, 2022

Highest available market price: $114k with 26 watchers


Incredible Hulk 1st appearance (publication year: 1962)

Highest sold: $92k on July 24, 2022

Highest available market price: $269k with 18 watchers


Incredible Hulk #181 (publication year: 1975)

Highest sold: $45k on July 19, 2022

Highest available market price: $269k with 391 watchers





Collectibles have plenty of categories from toys to home goods. They can be pretty hard to price, especially if you don't have any knowledge of the market. The best thing to do is find out which collectibles are trending right now and do some research on what makes them valuable or desirable. The age of the item (aka vintage) does not always mean it is valuable, there are many factors that can drive up the market demand such as limited production releases, a signature from a famous person, errors and misprints, and made with materials that no longer exist.


According to eBay's analytics, here are the top 3 collectibles and what type of items sold for big bucks between November 2021 and November 2022:


Military Equipment & WWII military items


Military Pins

These are popular collectibles, and they can be quite valuable. While many people think of military pins as being from the United States, they are actually from all over the world. There is a great deal of variation in military pins, making them an interesting and unique collection. One thing to keep in mind when collecting military pins is that they are often sold as a collection lot. The rewards can be great, as a single collection of 400+ military pins can be worth $1,000 or more.


military pins


Military Medals 

These medals are similar to military pins in that they are awarded to members of the armed forces for their service. However, medals are often awarded for specific acts of heroism or valor, while pins are generally given for completing a tour of duty or for participating in a particular campaign. Medals are also typically larger and more ornate than pins, and they are usually worn on the chest rather than on the lapel. While medals are typically awarded by governments, they can also be purchased by collectors. In March 2022, one collection lot of military medals sold for $4,400 at auction. These medals came from all over the world and represented different branches of the military. Whether you're a collector or a member of the armed forces, military medals make an impressive addition to any display.


military medals


Omega Watches

For watch enthusiasts, Omega is a well-known name. The company has a long history dating back to 1848, and it has been involved in some of the most important moments in timekeeping. Omega was one of the main suppliers of watches to Great Britain's ministry of defense and allies during WWII. More recently, the company made headlines when one of its watches sold for $5,400 at an auction in January 2022.


watch collection



Decorative Collectibles


Katherines Collections

They are a well-known maker of high-end holiday decorations. The company has been in business for over 30 years and has built up a devoted following among fans of holiday decor. Katherine's Collection releases a limited-edition series of decorations for holidays like Halloween and Easter, and each piece is meticulously crafted and designed to be a collectible. In March 2022, one of the company's dolls sold for $1,100 at an auction. The doll, which was part of the company's "spring decor" collection, was just one of many highly sought-after pieces in Katherine's Collection. While the prices for the company's products may be out of reach for some people, there is no denying the quality and craftsmanship that goes into each and every piece.


katherines collections


Vintage Pyrex

This classic kitchenware was first introduced in the early 1900s and has been a household staple ever since. While Pyrex is now made from tempered glass, the original dishes were made from borosilicate glass, which is much rarer and more valuable. The prices of vintage Pyrex are set by two factors: demand and rarity. For collectors, they sought after Pyrex which was made in the 1950s to late 1970s when the dishes were still made from borosilicate glass. In October of 2020, one casserole dish sold for a whopping $7,386! So, if you happen to come across some vintage Pyrex of your own, you may be sitting on a gold mine.


vintage pyrex



If you love music and art, then you might want to start collecting concert posters. While most people think of concert posters as just a piece of paper, they can actually be quite valuable. Vintage posters from iconic concerts can sell for a lot of money, and even newer posters can be worth a decent amount. For example, on October 2022 a set of 12 vintage, original, rock concert posters sold for $12,000 on eBay.


vintage posters


Collectible Lighters, Matchboxes, and Other Smoking Supplies


S.T. Dupont 

They are a French company that specializes in luxury lighters. These lighters are made with high-quality materials and often feature diamond and gold accents. In April 2022, one of the company's lighters sold for $72,000 at an auction. The company's products are celebrated for their beauty and craftsmanship, and they are prized by collectors around the world. Though they are not cheap, S.T Dupont's lighters are considered to be worth the investment, and they are sure to bring their owners years of enjoyment.


S.T. Dupont


Antique Matchbox Holders

In recent years, there has been a growing interest in vintage matchboxes. These tiny boxes are not only collectible, but they can also be quite valuable. For example, a matchbox holder made of sterling silver sold for $425 at auction in August 2022. Whether made of sterling silver or bronze, these tiny boxes are highly sought-after by collectors and can fetch a high price at auction.


antique matchbox


Elie Bleu 

They are a luxury French manufacturer of humidors and is highly regarded as the ultimate luxury piece for any cigar aficionado. The humidors are handmade in very small numbers which is why their cigar boxes (and cabinets) are so rare and expensive. One humidor sold for $5,400 in October 2022. Elie Bleu also offers a wide range of other cigar accessories such as cutters, cases, and lighters. While their products are certainly not cheap, they are definitely worth the price for any true cigar lover.


elie blue cigar box





The items in a memorabilia collection are usually connected to an important event or person and can be anything from old jerseys worn by sports stars of yesteryear on up. The most popular types include collectible cards for baseball players who've had their careers ended before they were inducted into the Hall-of-Fame (although there is no limit as long as people remember those moments), posters showcasing famous sporting events where these competitors played particularly well; even clothing and accessories from a famous concert or event.


Nirvana Signed or Vintage Items

In the early 1990s, Nirvana was one of the most popular bands in the world. In the years since Kurt Cobain's untimely passing, Nirvana has maintained a strong cult following. As a result, signed or vintage items from the band are highly coveted by collectors. In December 2021, a vintage Nirvana t-shirt sold for $7,000 on eBay.




Rookie Sports Cards

For some people, collecting autographs is a fun hobby. They might attend special events where their favorite celebrities will be in attendance, or they might purchase items that have already been signed. Some people are willing to pay large sums of money for rare or unique signatures especially if that celebrity is deceased or retired. One collector's item was signed by Aaron Judge that sold for $1.4 million on September 2022. While this may seem like a lot of money to some people, for others see it as an investment.


Rookie Sports Cards


Sports Jersey

It's no secret that sports jerseys can sell for a lot of money. In August 2022, a Nate Schmidt jersey sold for a whopping $42,075. That's just one example of the high prices that some jerseys can fetch. Of course, not all jerseys are worth such a high price tag. In general, the most valuable jerseys are those worn by famous athletes during significant moments in their careers. For example, a jersey worn by Babe Ruth during his legendary "called shot" home run would be worth far more than a jersey worn by an anonymous player from the same era. As a result, the value of a sports jersey depends largely on its history and associations.


Sports Jerseys


Coca Cola 

When it comes to iconic American brands, there are few that are more well-known than Coca-Cola. The company has been around for over a century, and in that time it has amassed a loyal following of fans who love anything and everything vintage Coca Cola. From signs and glass bottles to vending machines, collectors are willing to pay big money for Coke memorabilia. In December 2021, a 1935 porcelain sign sold for $16,655 at auction - proving that the Coke collectibles market is still going strong. If you're lucky enough to own any old Coke items, you could be sitting on a small fortune!


Vintage Coca-Cola


If you're looking to sell your old collectibles on eBay, you should keep an eye out for any rare or hard-to-find items that might be in good condition and have high market demand. Some tips include checking online forums and marketplaces for collectibles, doing research on past sales to get an idea of what your items might be worth, and making sure to properly grade and describe your items in the listing. With a little know-how and some careful research, you can make good money selling your old collectibles online!


You might also like: 10 Great Marketplaces Every Reseller Should Consider

Vendoo Subscribe Blog!